(716) 438-7452

Tater Cakes Bakeshop
Tater Cakes Bakeshop
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Cake Gallery
  • Shop
  • Christmas 2023
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Cake Gallery
    • Shop
    • Christmas 2023

(716) 438-7452

  • Sign In
  • My Account

  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com

  • My Account

  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Cake Gallery
  • Shop
  • Christmas 2023

Account

  • My Account

  • Sign out

  • Sign In
  • My Account

Cutoff for Friday/Saturday cake and cupcake orders is Wednesday at 6pm. 

All other cake/cupcake orders require 48 hours notice.  


  

Please note- we are not a gluten or nut free bakery. 

Our products may come in contact and are made on shared equipment. 


Online ordering is currently only available for Christmas pre-orders.

Cake Flavors

Cake Flavors

White, White Almond, Chocolate, Yellow, Sprinkle, Cherry Chip, Cookies n Cream, Lemon, Carrot, Snickerdoodle, Strawberry, Orange, Red Velvet. 

Fillings

Included in price- 

Buttercream (Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Peanut butter, Cookies n' cream, or Cinnamon),


Available for small additional fee- 

Cream cheese,

Fruit (Strawberry, Lemon, and Seedless Raspberry),

Bavarian Cream, Chocolate Bavarian Cream


Frosting

Buttercream (Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Cookies n' cream, or Cinnamon) 

All prices include sales tax unless otherwise noted.

Cupcakes

Cupcake flavors & Pricing

Round Cakes

Cake prices include choice of cake flavor, buttercream filling, and frosting. Prices are starting points and may have additional charges based on fillings, additional detail work, toppings, nuts, images, characters, and fondant. Add a printed image onto a cake, starting at $4.99 +tax

6" Round

$21.99+tax

Serves 8-10

3 Layer Cake

8" Round

$28.99+tax

Serves 12-15

 3 Layer Cake 

10" Round

$42.99+tax

Serves 20

3 Layer Cake 

12" Round

$57.99+tax

Serves 25

3 Layer Cake

Smash Cake

$10.99+tax

With any cake order. Simple design to match theme of main cake. White cake only. 

Dessert Cakes

$25+tax

Check out our assorted varieties 

Sheet Cakes

Cake prices include choice of cake flavor, buttercream filling, and frosting. Prices are starting points and may have additional charges based on filling selected, additional detail work, toppings, nuts, images, characters, and fondant. Add a printed image onto a cake, starting at $4.99 +tax

1/2 Sheet

$50.99+tax

Serves 30-40

2 Layer Cake

Full Sheet

$91.49+tax

Serves 80-90

2 Layer Cake

Dessert Cakes

Want something different than a traditional cake?

Loaded Chocolate Peanut Butter

 Chocolate Cake with a peanut butter butter cream filling, chocolate butter cream on the outside, covered with chocolate ganache drips, and peanut butter swirls. Peanut butter candy adds that extra peanut butter touch. 

Order Online

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Carrot cake with cream cheese filling, covered in vanilla butter cream frosting, and topped with our caramel fudge drip and toasted pecans. 

Order Online

Toasted Coconut

Coconut flavored cake with vanilla butter cream frosting and covered in toasted coconut.  

Order Online

Cookies and Cream Overload

Cookies and cream cake, filled with cookies and cream butter cream, covered in cookies and cream butter cream, topped with a chocolate ganache drip, and full Oreo cookies. 

Order Online

Chocolate Overload

Chocolate cake, choice of chocolate filling, iced in rich chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache, and topped with chocolate curls. 

Order Online

Cassata Cake

Delicious almond flavored cake, filled with fresh chocolate chip cannoli filling, frosted in our homemade vanilla buttercream, garnished on the side with mini chocolate chips, toasted almonds on the top, and maraschino cherries.   

Order Online

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

A large version of our chocolate chip cookie

Rectangle

$25

Serves 20

Circle

$17

Serves 12

Cupcakes

Dozen Traditional

$20

Traditional cupcakes consist of cake and buttercream swirl. Each dozen can be split up into 2 flavors. 

Flavors can be found here

Half Dozen Traditional

$10

Traditional cupcakes consist of cake and buttercream swirl. 

Gourmet/Featured flavors of the week

$25/ dozen

Gourmet cupcakes include toppings/toppers, flavors, detail work, and/or fillings. Featured flavors change each Tuesday and go on until Saturday. 

Gourmet/Featured flavors of the week

$13.50/ half dozen

 Gourmet cupcakes include toppings/toppers, flavors, detail work, and/or fillings. Featured flavors change each Tuesday and go on until Saturday.  

From the cookie jar

Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Ginger Snap, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Butterfinger, Sugar, Sprinkle, Molasses, Cookies 'n Cream, Chocolate-Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Peanut butter.

Dozen

$12

Can be individually wrapped for additional $1/dz.

Tray of Cookies

$29.49+ tax

2 1/2 Dozen cookies displayed on a tray. Up to 3 varieties. 

Order Online

Cutout Cookies

We're currently not accepting any custom cutout cookie orders. We only have cutout cookies for sale on certain holidays (Easter, Mothers Day, Fathers Day, Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas)

Pastries

Flavors vary in our case.

Turnovers, Pastry Hearts

$2

20 mini pastry hearts on a tray $10.99 +tax

Order Online!

Danish

2.50

Cheese or Fruit

Butter Croissants

$2

Filled Croissants

$2.50

Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter

Scones

$2.00 /ea.

Chocolate Chip, Orange Cranberry, Lemon Poppy Seed, Blueberry, Irish Cream (seasonal), Orange, Maple Walnut, Maple Pecan, Cookies 'n Cream, Cherry Chip, White Chocolate Pistachio, Cherry Almond 

Almond Bear Claws

$2.49 +tax

Jumbo Muffins

$1.50

6 Muffins- $8.10

Blueberry, Pistachio, Banana nut, Chocolate Chip, Oreo Cookie, Orange Cranberry, Cherry Almond, Lemon, Apple, Lemon Blueberry, Lemon poppy seed, pumpkin (seasonal), eggnog (seasonal). 

Almond Ring or Braid

$9.99+ tax

Danish Braid

$6.99 +tax

Lemon, Strawberry, Raspberry, Brown Sugar, Cherry, Apple, Blueberry

Cinnamon Buns

$3.50

Tray of 6 full size   $15.99+tax

Tray of 12 mini size $17.99+tax

Coffee Cake

$14.99 + tax

10" Round Cake. Cinnamon filling with crumb topping. 

Bagels

$1.65 /ea $10.45/dz

Saturday Only

Plain, Everything, Cheddar, Sesame Seed, Poppy Seed, Onion 

Side of cream cheese .79/ ea. $2.74 + tax dozen

Brownies

$2.25 /ea

Tray of 24 minis   $14.99+tax

Eclair

$ 3.56 +tax

Fresh, homemade choux pastry, filled with homemade vanilla custard and topped with delicious dark chocolate.   

Pies

Seasonal Pie Selection

Breakfast Trays

24 Hour notice on all trays.

Breakfast Assortment

Fruit filled turnovers, Fruit & cheese Danish, Scones, Cinnamon Rolls, and Croissants.

Small (2 of each) $22.99+tax

Medium (3 of each) $36.99+tax

Large (4 of each) $48.99+tax

Order Online!

Brunch Tray

12 mini cinnamon rolls, 10 strudel bites, and 6 mini croissants 

Small Tray (feeds 6-8 people) $24.99 +tax


12 mini cinnamon rolls, 15 strudel bites, and 10 mini croissants 

Large Tray (feeds 8-12 people) $31.99 +tax

Order Online!

All food is made on shared equipment that processes and/or contain gluten, nuts, dairy, eggs, etc.

Dessert tray option

Dozen cookies, dozen brownie bites, and 6 mini pastry hearts on a tray $21.99+tax

Order Online

Fresh Bread Schedule

Italian Bread

$3.50

Baked daily

Rye Bread

$3.50

Baked daily

French Bread

$3.50

Baked Tuesday and Wednesdays

8 Seed and Grain

$3.50

Baked Thursday and Fridays

Sourdough Bread

$3.50

Baked Friday and Saturdays

All bread is hand made without preservatives.

Pie List- Holidays 2023

$14.99 +tax

$14.99 +tax

$14.99 +tax

  • Apple
  • Cherry
  • Blueberry
  • Strawberry
  • Banana Cream 
  • Coconut Cream
  • Peanut Butter w/ Chocolate ganache in Chocolate crust  
  • Chocolate Cream w/ Chocolate Crust 
  • Lemon Meringue
  • Key Lime (Graham Cracker Crust)

All pies require 2 business day notice


$16.99+tax

$14.99 +tax

$14.99 +tax

  • Pecan 

Dessert Cake Ideas

Halloween Cake

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Loaded Chocolate Peanut Butter

Spooktacular treat with our Halloween Dessert Cake! This eerie delight features green drippy icing, a delightful array of candies, sprinkles, and even a "pot of ghoul". 

Order Online

Loaded Chocolate Peanut Butter

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Loaded Chocolate Peanut Butter

Peanut butter chocolate ganache chocolate cake

Chocolate Cake with a peanut butter butter cream filling, chocolate butter cream on the outside, covered with chocolate ganache drips, and peanut butter swirls. Peanut butter candy adds that extra peanut butter touch. $25+tax

Order Online

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Carrot Cake toasted pecans caramel fudge icing

6" Round carrot cake with cream cheese filling, covered in vanilla butter cream frosting, and topped with our caramel fudge drip and toasted pecans. $25+tax

Order Online

Toasted Coconut

Cookies and Cream Overload

Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake

Toasted Coconut cake toasted coconut

6" Round coconut flavored cake with vanilla butter cream frosting and covered in toasted coconut.  $25+tax

Order Online

Cookies and Cream Overload

Cookies and Cream Overload

Cookies and Cream Overload

Cookies and cream cake oreos

Cookies and cream cake, filled with cookies and cream butter cream, covered in cookies and cream butter cream, topped with a chocolate ganache drip, and full Oreo cookies. $25+tax

Order Online

Chocolate Overload

Cookies and Cream Overload

Cookies and Cream Overload

Chocolate cake, choice of chocolate filling, iced in rich chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache, and topped with chocolate curls. $25 +tax

Order Online

Cassata Cake

Cassata Cake

Cassata Cake

Cassata Cake

Delicious almond flavored cake, filled with fresh chocolate chip cannoli filling, frosted in our homemade vanilla buttercream, garnished on the side with mini chocolate chips, toasted almonds on the top, and maraschino cherries.  

$34.99+ tax

Order Online

Add a picture to your cake!

Print your photo on a cake. Photo cake edible image

Return and Refund Policy

 If you are not satisfied with your purchase, you can either return your order for a refund of the returned items or exchange it for something else. You can return or exchange your purchase for up to 5 days from the purchase date. Returned or exchanged products must be in the condition you received them and in the original box and/or packaging. 

We reserve the right to ask for proof of purchase.


Damaged product due to melting, improper transportation, animal damage, sitting/stepping on, and/or product was dropped/improperly carried are excluded. All bread sales (spoilage- due to lack of use of any preservatives), items that are labeled "Day Old" or reduced are sold "as is", are not eligible for any return/refund/replacement.   

Copyright © 2020 Tater Cakes Bakeshop - All Rights Reserved.

Tues-Fri: 7am-6pm   Sat: 9am-2pm  Sun/Mon- Closed

  • Employment Opportunities
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cupcakes
  • Employees
  • Donation Request

Powered by GoDaddy

Online ordering is currently only for Christmas menu preorders. Please call the bakery for all other ordering.

Christmas Hours

Friday, December 22: 7AM-6PM

Saturday, December 23: 9AM-2PM

Sunday, December 24: 9AM-12PM


We will be closed from 12/23-1/2/24. 

Reopening on Wednesday, January 3, 2024

Cookie Policy

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.

DeclineAccept & Close