Cutoff for Friday/Saturday cake and cupcake orders is Wednesday at 6pm.
All other cake/cupcake orders require 3-5 business days notice.
Everything else requires 1-2 business days.
Please note- we are not a gluten or nut free bakery.
Our products may come in contact and are made on shared equipment.
Featured Products
Cake Flavors
Cake Flavors
White, White Almond, Chocolate, Yellow, Sprinkle, Cherry Chip, Cookies n Cream, Lemon, Carrot, Snickerdoodle, Strawberry, Orange, Red Velvet.
Fillings
Included in price-
Buttercream (Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Peanut butter, Cookies n' cream, or Cinnamon),
Available for small additional fee-
Cream cheese,
Fruit (Strawberry, Lemon, and Seedless Raspberry),
Bavarian Cream, Chocolate Bavarian Cream
Frosting
Buttercream (Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Cookies n' cream, or Cinnamon)
All prices include sales tax unless otherwise noted.
Cupcakes
Round Cakes
Cake prices include choice of cake flavor, buttercream filling, and frosting. Prices are starting points and may have additional charges based on fillings, additional detail work, toppings, nuts, images, characters, and fondant. Please note we do not offer cakes completely finished in fondant. Add a printed image onto a cake, starting at $5
6" Round
$25
Serves 8-10
3 Layer Cake
8" Round
$32.75
Serves 12-16
3 Layer Cake
10" Round
$47.75
Serves 20-22
3 Layer Cake
12" Round
$64
Serves 24
3 Layer Cake
Smash Cake
$17
With any cake order. Simple design to match theme of main cake. White cake only.
Dessert Cakes
$28.25
Prices starting at $28.25
Sheet Cakes
Cake prices include choice of cake flavor, buttercream filling, and frosting. Prices are starting points and may have additional charges based on filling selected, additional detail work, toppings, nuts, images, characters, and fondant. Add a printed image onto a cake, starting at $5.
1/2 Sheet
$55
Serves 30-40
2 Layer Cake
Full Sheet
$99
Serves 80-90
2 Layer Cake
Dessert Cakes
Want something different than a traditional cake?
Loaded Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate Cake with a peanut butter butter cream filling, chocolate butter cream on the outside, covered with chocolate ganache drips, and peanut butter swirls. Peanut butter candy adds that extra peanut butter touch.
Caramel toasted pecan carrot cake
Carrot cake with cream cheese filling, covered in vanilla butter cream frosting, and topped with our caramel fudge drip and toasted pecans.
Toasted Coconut
Coconut flavored cake with vanilla butter cream frosting and covered in toasted coconut.
Cookies and Cream Overload
Cookies and cream cake, filled with cookies and cream butter cream, covered in cookies and cream butter cream, topped with a chocolate ganache drip, and full Oreo cookies.
Chocolate Overload
Chocolate cake, choice of chocolate filling, iced in rich chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache, and topped with chocolate curls.
Cassata Cake
Delicious almond flavored cake, with fresh chocolate chip cannoli filling. Frosted in our homemade vanilla buttercream and garnished on the side with mini chocolate chips. Toasted almonds on the top, and garnished with maraschino cherries.
Lemon Blueberry
Lemon cake with juicy blueberries baked in. Filled with blueberry buttercream, frosted in lemon buttercream, finished with blueberry buttercream accents.
Bear Claw
Based on our bear claw danish! White almond cake, filled with cream cheese buttercream, frosted in cinnamon buttercream, cream cheese drizzle, and finished with toasted almonds.
Milano Cake
White cake with chocolate fudge filling, frosted in a marbled vanilla and chocolate buttercream topped with Milano cookies.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
A large version of our chocolate chip cookie frosted with vanilla buttercream.
Rectangle
$28
Serves about 20
Circle
$20
Serves about 12
Cupcakes
Dozen Traditional
$20
Traditional cupcakes consist of cake and buttercream swirl. Each dozen can be split up into 2 flavors.
Half Dozen Traditional
$10
Traditional cupcakes consist of cake and buttercream swirl.
Gourmet/Featured flavors of the week
$27.50/ dozen
Gourmet cupcakes include toppings/toppers, flavors, detail work, and/or fillings. Featured flavors change each Tuesday and go on until Saturday.
Gourmet/Featured flavors of the week
$14.50/ half dozen
Gourmet cupcakes include toppings/toppers, flavors, detail work, and/or fillings. Featured flavors change each Tuesday and go on until Saturday.
From the cookie jar
Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Ginger Snap, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Butterfinger, Sugar, Sprinkle, Molasses, Cookies 'n Cream, Chocolate-Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Peanut butter.
Dozen
$14.50
Tray of Cookies
$35.49+ tax
2 1/2 Dozen cookies displayed on a tray. Up to 3 varieties.
Cutout Cookies
We only do Occasion/Seasonal cutouts in our case for purchase, we do not do custom orders. The following seasons we offer cutouts for sale- Valentines, Easter, Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas.
Pastries
Flavors vary in our case.
Turnovers
$2.50
Flakey fruit filled pastry.
Danish
$2.50
Cheese or Fruit
Danish Braid
$7.50
Lemon, Strawberry, Raspberry, Cherry, Apple, Blueberry, Cheese
Almond Ring
$10.50
Butter Croissants
$2.50
Chocolate Stuffed Croissants
$3
Dark chocolate bars filling with chocolate on top.
Scones
$2.00 /ea.
Baked daily- Chocolate Chip, Orange Cranberry, Cinnamon Brown Sugar. Other examples that are rotated- Lemon Poppy Seed, Blueberry, Irish Cream (seasonal), Orange, Maple Walnut, Maple Pecan, Cookies 'n Cream, Cherry Chip, White Chocolate Pistachio, Cherry Almond
Almond Bear Claws
$2.75
Sweet danish filled with our homemade almond paste filling topped with our creamcheese icing and toasted almonds.
Jumbo Muffins
$1.50
6 Muffins- $8.50
Blueberry, Pistachio, Banana nut, Chocolate Chip, Oreo Cookie, Orange Cranberry, Cherry Almond, Lemon, Apple, Lemon Blueberry, Lemon poppy seed, pumpkin (seasonal), eggnog (seasonal).
Cinnamon Buns
$4 /ea
6 full size or 12 mini size $21
Bagels
$2.00 /ea $13/dz
Saturday Only
Plain, Everything, Cheddar, Sesame Seed, Poppy Seed, Onion
Side of cream cheese $1/ ea. or $4 container
Brownies
$2.25 /ea
Tray of 24 minis $14.99+tax
Cream Horn
$3.50 /ea
Breakfast Trays
24 Hour notice on all trays.
Breakfast Assortment
Fruit filled turnovers, Fruit & cheese Danish, Scones, Cinnamon Rolls, and Croissants.
Small (2 of each) $29.99+tax
Medium (3 of each) $44.99+tax
Large (4 of each) $56.99+tax
Brunch Tray
12 mini cinnamon rolls, 10 strudel bites, and 6 mini croissants
Small Tray (feeds 6-8 people) $24.99 +tax
12 mini cinnamon rolls, 15 strudel bites, and 10 mini croissants
Large Tray (feeds 8-12 people) $31.99 +tax
All food is made on shared equipment that processes and/or contain gluten, nuts, dairy, eggs, etc.
Fresh Bread Schedule
Italian Bread
$3.50
Baked daily
Rye Bread
$3.50
Baked daily
French Bread
$3.50
Baked Tuesday and Wednesdays
8 Seed and Grain
$3.50
Baked Thursday and Fridays
All bread is hand made without preservatives.
Pie List
$16.50 /each
- Apple
- Cherry
- Blueberry
- Strawberry
- Banana Cream
- Coconut Cream
- Peanut Butter w/ Chocolate ganache in Chocolate crust
- Chocolate Cream w/ Chocolate Crust ($2 extra)
- Lemon Meringue
- Pecan ($2 extra)
All pies require 2 business day notice
We can print a picture and add it onto your cake!
Return and Refund Policy
If you are not satisfied with your purchase, you can either return your order for a refund of the returned items or exchange it for something else. You can return or exchange your purchase for up to 5 days from the purchase date. Returned or exchanged products must be in the condition you received them and in the original box and/or packaging.
We reserve the right to ask for proof of purchase.
To combat fraud, all refunds are issued back to the original method of payment or store credit (if requested).
Damaged product due to melting, improper transportation, animal damage, sitting/stepping on, and/or product was dropped/improperly carried are excluded. All bread sales (spoilage- due to lack of use of any preservatives), items that are labeled "Day Old" or reduced are sold "as is", are not eligible for any return/refund/replacement. Online orders/prepaid/items with a deposit- failure to pick up product or orders that are canceled within 48 hours of pick up, will result in forfeiture and will not be eligible for refund or store credit.
Copyright © 2025 Tater Cakes LLC- All Rights Reserved.
Tues-Fri: 7am-6pm Sat: 9am-2pm Sun/Mon- Closed
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.